The fifth World Wide Web conference was held at CNIT, La Défense in Paris from 6-10th May 1996. The conference began with a day of tutorials and workshops and concluded with a developer's day. The technical programme took place on the 7-9th May. In addition a Small to Medium Enterprises (SME) Forum was held on 9-10th May.
The WWW conference has certainly changed since the first conference was held at CERN in May 1994. It is difficult to believe that only two years have passed since that date. The conference has grown in size from 380 participants at the first conference, to over 2,000 in Paris.
I did not think there were any earth-shattering papers or announcements at the conference. However there were announcements in a number of areas of interest to me:
The conference consisted of paper sessions, panel sessions, invited presentations and W3C sessions. A summary of the sessions I attended follows.
The first paper session I attended was on Web Characteristics. The papers were:
Allison Woodruff et al's paper provided a useful summary on the usage of HTML tags in a large number of documents.
I was impressed by Tim Bray's paper on measuring the Web. This analysis covered connections to and from HTML documents. A VRML display of the Web was provided, which provided a graphical illustration of a number of features, including the size of a site, and the numbers of pointers from the site and the numbers of pointers to the site.
Tak Woon Yan et als paper provided an analysis of usage for an individual browsing a Web site, and used clustering techniques to suggest related pages which other users have accessed. This is likely to be a feature of commercial sites, such as virtual shopping malls ("We noticed you've access the tennis pages and the pages on holidays in the Bahamas. You might also be interested in our pages on camera equipment").
The next paper session I attended was on Document Structures in which the following papers were presented:
Stéphane Bonhomme and Cécile Roisin's paper described techniques for restructuring HTML documents (e.g. automatically converting a bulleted list to a table). The importance of having correctly structured documents was made very clear in this talk.
Vicenzo Della Mea et al's paper illustrated how they had added HTML tags to define a structure to a database application they had developed. This work was similar to Simon Dobson and Victoria Marshall's paper on Light-Weight Databases which was presented at a previous WWW conference.
Jan Paoli's paper described a technique for extending HTML based on extensions to the HTML DTD.
I then chaired a session on Browsing Aids:
Yoelle Maarek and Israel Ben Shaul described an interesting technique for automating management of bookmark files based on clustering techniques.
Fred Douglis et al described software for visualising changes to different generations of HTML documents.
Kirsten Jones' paper described a technique for providing state when navigating Web directory structures.
Stuart Weibel, Online Computer Library Center (OCLC), gave a presentation on Mending Our Net: Gathering, Describing, and Preserving Information in a Digital World. It was interesting to hear Stuart's introduction to the subject of meta-data: he described how IETF working group meeting resembled the film Groundhog Day, with every meeting seeming to repeat the discussion topics aired at previous meetings. In light of the difficultituies of advancing URN (Uniform Resource Names) Stuart suggested that PURLS (Persistent URLs) could have a role to play.
Bob Scheifler, X Consortium, then gave a talk on Broadway: Universal Access to Interactive Applications Over The Web. The goal of Broadway is to "provide universal access to interactive applications on the Web - the ability to locate and invoke remote applications via the Web and have their displays, including both graphics and audio, appear wherever you are, either as new top-level windows or embedded within a Web browser". For further information see the URL http://www.x.org/consortium/broadway.html
At the Developer's Day, Dave Raggett and Håkon Lie gave a summary of developments to HTML and Style Sheets. HTML 3.2 was announced, which should bring to an end the HTML extensions wars which were threatening to pull apart the Web community.
HTML 3.2 will include a number of widely deployed features, including:
In addition it will include a number of widely-adopted HTML extensions (such as <BODY BACKGROUND>, <BIG> and <SMALL>).
Following these two presentations, a speaker from Netscape was introduced, and then Chris Wilson (Microsoft) gave a talk on the issues associated with writing software to support style sheets. Chris described the importance of document structure and tag containers. He described the difficulties of implementing support for document containing invalid HTML constructs For example:
<B>Bold text<I>Bold Italic text</B> what's this</I>what's this?
can be interpreted in a number of ways. When attempting to analyse such invalid HTML constructs, errors could be introduced (e.g. using tools to create style sheets). For example, the example shown above could be interpreted as:
However, automatically generating HTML tags can cause problems, if, for example, <FRAME> or <FORM> tags had to be generated. (Note the high proportion of document containing errors given in the URL http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/~woodruff/inktomi/results_syntax.html).
Chris made the following recommendations:
Following the presentations there was a panel session. The following questions were asked:
Although 58 papers were selected for presentation in the parallel sessions at the Conference, it was disappointing that only three (Neil Smith's paper on The UK National Web Cache - The State of the Art, Dave Ingham et al's paper on Fixing The "Broken Link" Problem: The W3Objects Approach and Leslie Carr et al's paper on Open Information Systems) were from the UK HE community.
At the first WWW conference many of the speakers gave their presentations using OHP foils. At that conference only one speaker (Dave Raggett) gave his presentation using the Web. This time, in comparison, all speakers were requested to make their slides available in HTML format. The files were then displayed using a Web browser (Netscape). Although this did not provide the layout control available using desktop presentation packages such as PowerPoint, it was good to see the Web being used in this way. Indeed two speakers (Chris Lilley and Håkon Lie) used the Arena browser with style sheets to provide a high degree of control over the screen display.
The higlight of the social programme was the conference buffet, held in Le Louvre. A modern exhibit was on display at the museum. Robert Cailliau brought along Tim Berners-Lee's original NeXT computer, which was used to produce the initial WWW browser and server.
The low point of the conference occured on the Sunday. After registering I managed to find a computer and accessed the Carling football pages, only to discover that Manchester United were winning, and Newcastle were drawing :-(
Details of the conference are available at the URL http://www.w3.org/pub/Conferences/WWW5/Welcome.html
Conference papers are available at the URL http://www.w3.org/pub/Conferences/WWW5/fich_html/paper-sessions.html
Details on next year's WWW Conference are available at the URL http://www6conf.slac.stanford.edu/